Ways of Knowing (4P's)
A principled and rigorous taxonomy of the different ways of knowing.
| Description | Cognate | Memory | Imparts | Realizes | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Propositional | Knowing that... | Dianoia | Semantic | Beliefs | Truth |
| Procedural | Knowing how... | Techne | Procedural | Skills & Techniques | Power |
| Perspectival | Knowing what it is like... | Noesis | Episodic | Perspectives | Presence |
| Participatory | Knowing by being with... | Gnosis | "The Self" | Affinities & Affordances | Belonging & Meaning in Life |
Propositional Knowing
- Related to the ancient Greek notion of dianoia.
- "Knowing that" something is true.
- Stored in semantic memory as knowledge of facts.
- Results in beliefs.
- Closely tied with language and justification.
- Our current culture is a kind of propositional tyranny (overly fixated on this type of knowing).
- Standard of realness: true or false; conviction; about honing logic to make accurate truth statements.
Procedural Knowing
- Related to the ancient Greek notion of techne.
- "Knowing how" to do something.
- Stored in procedural memory as embodied skill.
- Results in skills and techniques.
- Can be trained.
- Standard of realness: powerful or not; sense that interactions with the world are making a difference and altering the course of events.
Perspectival Knowing
- Related to the ancient Greek notion of noesis.
- "Knowing what it is like" to be here and now.
- Stored in episodic memory as contextual awareness.
- Results in perspectives.
- Knowing through your state of consciousness; a point of view; situational awareness; embodied perception.
- Standard of realness: presence; a sense of being "here and now"; truth as realization.
Participatory Knowing
- Related to the ancient Greek notion of gnosis.
- "Knowing by being with" Self and World.
- Stored in a strange kind of memory called "The Self".
- Results in affinities and affordances.
- You and reality have been co-shaped to fit together. The Self participates in creating World, and the World participates in creating the Self (a transjective experience).
- Standard of realness: a sense of being connected and in a dialogue with reality; belonging; meaning in life.
Footnotes
-
The 4P's taxonomy was created by Dr. John Vervaeke and first seen in Awakening from the Meaning Crisis. ↩